Forecasting
Why surf forecasts disagree: same swell, different numbers
Surfline says 6 to 10 ft. Windy says 3 ft. Usually both are reading the same swell. They print different heights, from different models, through different rulers. Here is how to tell which number to believe.
The short answer
Most of the gap is the ruler, not the model.
A model gives the height of the swell in deep water. A surfer rides the face of a breaking wave, and the sets run bigger still. Apps print different points on that path and call them all "wave height". Check which one your app prints before you compare.
Three heights for one swell
Swell height is the significant height in deep water. It is what a buoy measures and what Windy and most model charts show.
Breaking height is the height once the wave shoals and breaks. It depends on the period: a long-period swell grows much more on the way in.
Face height is what a surfer calls the wave, trough to lip, on a set. Surfline and BarrelFare print this one.
Here is one swell, 2.6 ft in deep water, run through each step at four periods. We used the same physics the BarrelFare app uses, at an open beach.
| Period | Swell height (deep water) | Breaking height | Set face |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6 s | 2.6 ft | 3.4 ft | 2.4 ft |
| 10 s | 2.6 ft | 4.2 ft | 3.3 ft |
| 14 s | 2.6 ft | 4.8 ft | 4.6 ft |
| 18 s | 2.6 ft | 5.3 ft | 5.6 ft |
Breaking height: Komar and Gaughan (1972). Set face: the BarrelFare app's face height at an open beach, calibrated to Surfline's printed ranges (× 0.7).
The deep-water number does not change across the rows. The face does. That is why a groundswell can read small on a chart and break overhead. It is also why a chart that ignores period can call a windswell and a groundswell the same day.
What we found when we checked
In July 2026 we put our forecast for Lower Trestles next to Surfline's. Surfline called the week 6 to 10 ft. We showed about 3 ft. It looked like our model was weak.
It was not. Open-Meteo's model had the swell at 2.7 ft and 12.2 seconds in deep water. Run through the breaking physics and the set factor, that is a face of about 7 ft. That sits inside Surfline's range. The models agreed. We had printed the deep-water height and called it the face.
We fixed the ruler. Then our faces ran high, so in August we tuned them. We compared 110 forecast days at eight breaks with Surfline's printed range. Before the tune, 29 of the 110 fell inside it. After, 72 did. Most of the rest come down to each break's own reef and sand.
The other reasons apps disagree
- The wind model. Every wave model takes its wind from a weather model. If the weather models place a storm differently, the swell differs too.
- The wave model. NOAA's WAVEWATCH III, ECMWF's WAM and Météo-France's MFWAM handle swell decay and island shadows a little differently.
- The grid. A coarse grid cell can sit on land near a break, or miss a narrow swell window. Apps then read a cell further out, where the swell is bigger.
- The tuning. Surfline adjusts its forecast at each break with machine learning, trained on years of reports and cameras. Surf-forecast.com and Windy show the model with little or no tuning.
- The swell trains. A sea often holds two or three swells at once. Some apps add them into one height. Others show each one. Windguru shows the combined sea.
Which number to trust
- Compare like with like. Put the swell height and period from each app side by side, not the headline number.
- Watch the period. If two apps agree on height but not period, the faces will differ. Trust the longer period only if a buoy upstream shows it.
- Watch the trend. When the models move together run after run, the swell is real. When they split, the forecast is weak.
- Check a buoy. It is the only number that is not a forecast. Read how to read a surf buoy.
For how forecasts are built from wind to wave, read how surf forecasts work.
Questions
Why is Surfline higher than Windy?
Windy shows the swell height in deep water. Surfline shows the breaking face of the sets. On a long-period swell the face can be more than twice the deep-water height.
Is Surfline more accurate than the free models?
Surfline tunes its forecast at each break, which helps at fussy breaks. Underneath, it reads the same kind of physics models. On open coasts, the free models usually see the same swell.
What height does BarrelFare show?
The face of the sets at each break. We work it out from the model's swell height and period, the break's swell window and its own focus. We calibrate it against Surfline's printed ranges.
Fly when the swell shows up.
The app watches the forecast and the fares at every break we cover, and tells you when they line up.
Cheap flights to firing waves, in your inbox every week.
Cheap Waves: cheap flights to firing waves. Unsubscribe anytime.